The Doctor Weighs In

Brian Klepper

This week TDWI is delighted to take our turn hosting Health Care Wonk Review, a collection that highlights some of health policy's best observers. The quality of these 14 posts is very high, and well worth your time.

As HWR has gained visibility and popularity, the number of submissions has risen. We couldn't publish them all, so chose the ones we thought were must-reads across industry sectors. (Apologies to those we didn't include this time.)

Before we begin, a quick announcement. Envision Solutions, LLC and Trusted.MD Network have launched the second annual global survey of healthcare bloggers.  The companies are producing this poll to shed additional light on why people blog about health-related subjects.  Click on the link to learn about and take the survey.  The study will close on October 15.

Now onto the show!

Physician Temper Tantrums. Over at Managed Care Matters, Joe Paduda picks a scab and elicits a (deliciously) minor furor. He argues that when payors use the results of claims data analysis to encourage patients to see better performing doctors, they are well within their rights as purchasers. He also notes (and I agree) that when doctors reject out-of-hand claims data as inherently flawed and inappropriate to provide quality analysis, they may not appreciate the progress in the available tools and methods, and may be simply defensive. Actually, he says "their actions look more childish than professional from here." A provocative piece.

No Docs in This Box. Retail medical clinics are popping up all over as an inexpensive alternative to a full-blown practice or the ER. Traditional providers are crying foul, but InsureBlog's Bob Vineyard suggests this is the pot calling the kettle black.

Abusing The Orphan Drug Law To Rip Off Customers. In a damning indictment of a drug company's business practices, David Williams at the Health Business Blog discusses Questcor Pharmaceuticals announcement about “a new strategy and business model for H.P. Acthar Gel(R).”

What Are The Real Savings In Medical Tourism. MedTripInfo's Michael Horowitz analyzes the probable total savings for a hip replacement obtained overseas. They're substantial.

Medical Justice League of America. The Sentinel Effect's Richard Eskow describes a new group that provides "gag order" forms to dissuade patients from reviewing their docs online, and also promises to "relentlessly" fight med mal lawsuits." The situation he relates would be hilarious if it weren't so lopsided and scary.

Make Sure Your Online SaaS Vendors Are Appliance Capable. The Healthcare IT Guy, Shahid Shah, provides sage advice on why you should not depend on "software in a cloud" without a backup plan. With big outages from Microsoft, Skype, eBay, and PayPal recently making headlines, it is wise to make sure you're protected. A fascinating and smart look at the pitfalls and realities of letting other companies be responsible for your mission-critical IT functions.

What The Lumenati Are Saying May Surprise You.  The ever-entertaining Matthew Holt is making the final dash toward hosting the Health 2.0 conference, where the discussion will focus on a significant portion of market-based reform, and the players will be none of the usual suspects. Meanwhile, back at The Health Care Blog, he ticks off some surprisingly lucid health care insights from the most unexpected sources.

Mitt Romney's Health Plan - A Foot In Each Canoe.  Over at Health Care Policy and Marketplace Review, Bob Laszewski wryly observes that conservative Presidential candidate Mitt Romney would like to have it both ways. He gloats over the Massachusetts reform he helped to engineer while assuring his political base that it wouldn't work elsewhere. (It's also not yet clear that it is going to work in Massachusetts.) It's a delightful bit of political dissonance, seen through the clarity of Bob's highly polished health policy lens.

BiPolar Diagnosis in Children: Another Epidemic? Here at The Doctor Weighs In, the erudite Dov Michaeli recounts a recent review article from the Archives of General Psychiatry. Between 1994-1995 and 2002-2003, an 8 year period, the rate of bi-polar diagnoses in children increased 40 fold! He lists a range of possible explanations for the epidemic, but settles, gloomily and cynically, on money. By explicating an immense but relatively obscure problem, he lays bare a pervasive trend that's corroding our health system. A must read!

Conflicted View on the Pitfalls of Government-Sponsored Comparative Effectiveness Research. In a withering analysis, Roy Poses at Healthcare Renewal rebuts a recent commentary by WSJ Editorial darling Scott Gottlieb. Dr. Gottlieb disparaged government-sponsored research as biased against costly drugs, while ignoring similar and more odious flaws in private sector research practices. AND Dr. Gottlieb conveniently neglects to disclose that he's associated with the biotechnology sector. Superb.

To Hell and Beyond: Dave Holland's Terrible Story. At Workers' Comp Insider, Julie Ferguson points to a particularly gruesome work-related accident by way of reminding us that these incidents are still all too common. Julie's perspective is particularly poignant, because it is also a reminder that what lies beneath the day-to-day work  of the people who write for and read this review is the vital goal of preventing and managing the suffering that is too often a part of life.

Katrina: Two Years Later Are Health Systems Better Prepared?  On the second anniversary of Hurricane Katrina, NewsHour correspondent Tom Bearden asks a coastal area provider if the health systems are now better prepared. The short answer is "No," according to the  interview excerpted by Jane Hiebert-White on Health Affairs Blog.

Cookbook Medicine Saves Lives.   A pretty good cook (I can vouch for her!) as well as a physician, The Doctor Weighs In's Pat Salber relates the substance of a July 23 article in the Archives of Internal Medicine. She describes a new heart failure guideline that improves outcomes when followed by clinicians, and details the range and depths of those improvements. She concludes with a quote from  the lead author, telling us that if these protocols were followed in hospitals across the country, they would result in 40,000 fewer deaths and 1.4 million fewer hospital days annually. Keeping in mind that this is just one condition in the vast complex of health care, it is a deeply compelling point.

Reform's Tougher Problem. I've been a bedouin lately, wandering from oasis to oasis, grateful for the chance to publish on Pat Salber's The Doctor Weighs In, Bob Laszewski's Health Care Policy and Marketplace Review, and on Matthew Holt's Health Care Blog. This post, placed on Matt's site, summarizes what I've learned working for several years on the reform problem. I now believe that meaningful change can only occur through the leadership of the non-health care business community, the one group with more power and influence than the financially conflicted health care sector. Non-health care's business leaders will pursue this effort, not because they care about health care or social justice, but because health care's impending instability will threaten the stability of their own econonic environments.

Thanks again to Health Wonk Review for letting us host, and thank you for stopping by.